Question about judges
-
The 9-9 rounds happen WAY more often than they would in a real fight. I agree with Reaper here. If the round is somewhat close before the KD it should still be 10-8. The game leans on the side of giving 9-9 rounds too often and it's unrealistic. It should be a rare occasion. Not to mention it throws out split decision wins when 2 judges have a fight a draw, versus a majority draw like it should.
-
The real world is unrealistic. OB counts the punches and can be way more accurate than any RL judge. So if the round is 9-9, it's fair.
-
@admin Exactly... It is maths. It's computer calculated instead of an actual opinionated judge. If you want a 10-8 round, you have to dictate the round after the knockdown. Not get beat up and land a lucky punch
-
@Faker Dude thats half the reason why i beat you. I understand that but you shouldnt be able to throw 30 punches and get hit over 100 times and knocked down then get a 9 - 9 round. More work needs to be done about the stamina.
-
@Reaper Just completely false. You live in a fantasy world. It's calculated and 100% accurate.
-
@admin Accuracy? you gotta be kidding me. I always win on the first judge because i am fairly accurate in fact i almost did win in this fight with that judge but sometimes its just silly across the board. Faker is agreeing with you because if you changed anything he would be done. He spams the hell out of you with little pitty patty punches. Crank is like a Faker V2 lol.
Both styles are ok for winning but not really for long term winning thats why they both cant get over a 20 win streak. I think John had the best balanced style and even he threw more than 30 punches per round lol. mikkel can you at least look at this?
-
@Reaper He doesn't need to look at anything, you saw what he said. And the reason you win judge 1 is because you spam jabs and judge 1 is scored on # of punches landed. I could hit you with 10 big hooks and you could land 11 jabs and you'll win on judge 1. It's not accuracy you nincompoop, it's just the number of punches you land. How about instead of crying to Mikkel to change it, you just get gud and ask him exactly what each judge scores on?
-
@admin I know your joking about the real world too lol
-
@Faker Accuracy should come in to scoring fool. You definitely have not boxed before and you have to be a casual fan. Id rather see more scoring on accuracy then stamina.
@Mikkel Can you maybe change it to more accuracy based? that would make more sense. Not stamina based, Faker can throw a thousand little pitty patter spam and miss like hell but only get a few hits on then win the round. Doesnt make sense man.
-
@admin At least make a poll about this issue to see what the community wants so you dont lose more players? You lost a lot of players when you changed it last time all those years ago. Some tweaking might be needed for sure so i think you should listen to the growing community.
-
Yeah jabs seem to score just as well as an uppercut or power body shot, etc. Those should be weighted differently. If Canelo had these judges he'd have 2-3 more losses. If power shots counted for more, people would take more chances and it would create better action. When the crowd "ooh's and aah's" that should maybe count for extra with the judges? Jabs score too heavily with the judges.
If a round is somewhat close, and there's a knockdown, the round should be 10-8. The only time 9-9 should occur is if you got a lucky knockdown and got your ass handed to you otherwise.
-
@Reaper Yeah, I don't think Fury vs Wilder was a good example because he didn't really dominate that round the way you get dominated on OB. Talk about real boxing - you turn your back every time you get hit, you look like an absolute retard. Should have done more sparring - hopping around like a bellend. And you're fighting in a headguard with what 12 oz gloves? Yet you're still getting rocked
-
@The-Sniper Sorry but what you guys are saying is absolute nonsense. Judges have been like this since 2003 and you guys are the only 2 who make complaints. You wonder now with all these players here, is everyone really against me like you've been saying all this time? Or are you 2 just 🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡
-
@Faker said in Question about judges:
@The-Sniper Sorry but what you guys are saying is absolute nonsense. Judges have been like this since 2003 and you guys are the only 2 who make complaints. You wonder now with all these players here, is everyone really against me like you've been saying all this time? Or are you 2 just 🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡
Faker you are misinformed. The guys on now are asking these questions directly in the chat and not on the forums. Crank and Unstop and I had a discussion about all of this earlier with several points made. I was asked my opinion. It's not black and white. No one is complaining, just merely making observations. Others are making pushes for changes as well. You're out of the loop apparently. It's been a productive discussion and people are entitled to their own opinions. We can agree to disagree.
Notice things have been peaceful with all the activity. Let's try to keep the peace shall we? This shit is unnecessary.
-
@Faker I dont think you have ever boxed or you have limited boxing knowledge. Ever heard of riding a shot? I was turning with the shot and trying to slip. That was early on in my career so whats your problem dude?
I was moving on my toes also and i had a very awkward opponent and i never got rocked, ever heard of getting caught off balance? nor have i ever been rocked in a boxing match. I have been rocked in sparring but never knocked down.
-
@Reaper You're hurt because you're getting pointed out that you were a white collar level boxer. You like to tell everyone that you had a touted amateur career when really you didn't do shit. Early on into your career???? When you were what? 25 years old? Riding a shot??? Don't even get me started, you went flying with the shot. He's not an awkward opponent, he's just running into you and you're doing nothing about it. Fair enough it's your first fight against a southpaw but this isn't rocket science, there's someone infront of you hitting you, do something about it. He rocked you so hard he had you punching air. Punch drunk, don't get into a ring, keep your faculties - boxing isn't a sport for a tough-man army vet. It's a thinking sport. And you've clearly shown all of us that you're damn near retarded.
-
@Faker Thanks for confirming you have never boxed. I have never done white collar either.
-
@Reaper No one said you did, that's just the level you're at. These white collar boxers would kick the shit out of you
-
Here is what it is @Reaper
The first judge recognizes most punches landed in the round. So if the pity pat jabs land more than your opponent you will win that round because of punches landed.
Example: 5 Jabs landed(minimal damage done)<---Winner
3 Rights land(big damage)<---LoserThe second and 3rd Judges care more about damage done, 3rd throws a bit of defense/counter punching in the equation.
Example: 5 Jabs landed(minimal damage done)<---Loser
3 Rights land(big damage)<---WinnerI do agree, stamina loss is a bit much and heavily impacts the fighting style of the game, that is something that should be looked into. @Mikkel @admin Maybe you can turn off the stamina for like a weekend? We can test it out, I'm sure everyone would like a tweak even if temporary.
-
@Unstoppable yeah thanks unstop I always win on the 1st judge but the 2nd judge is mainly my problem then the 3rd judge i can win on that judge at times. I just find it boring because you barely can throw punches and i dont have time to go 15 rounds every time i fight wtf man? because that is literally what you have to do if you want to fight in title fights or top 5 fights which go 12 rounds because you dont have enough stamina to knock someone out.
I have beaten most players in this new stamina format so its no problem, i am just not finding this game that much fun anymore because people are so bothered about their stamina these days that they look to go 15 rounds. I went 15 rounds with @Faker just by leaning, he didnt even manage to knock me out either. i was so bored i just did that for fun. I even knocked him down and got a couple of rounds. Crazyiness!
Ok enough of that rant, i just have to accept this game isnt meant to be realistic which is fair enough.
